Uncategorized

Papa Stronsay Missing Monk: Justin Evans Found Dead After Search in Orkney

lastchapterstories.name.ng| Verified

Justin Evans, also known as Brother Ignatius Maria. Photograph published with coverage of the missing-person search.

The disappearance of Justin Evans, a 24-year-old New Zealand monk who went missing from Papa Stronsay in Scotland’s Orkney Islands, ended in tragedy after his body was recovered from the surrounding waters in May 2026.

Evans, also known as Brother Ignatius Maria, was last seen at Golgotha Monastery shortly before midnight on April 11. His disappearance prompted an extensive search involving Police Scotland, coastguard teams, specialist officers, boats, helicopters and divers.

His body was discovered near Stronsay on May 6 and formally identified several days later. Authorities subsequently concluded that there were no suspicious circumstances and that no further action was required following the investigation.

The Orcadian Online+1

The case has returned to public attention in November following new reporting about the investigation and a documentary episode of Highland Cops examining the search for the missing monk.

Who Was Justin Evans?

Justin Evans was a New Zealander originally from Christchurch who had been living at Golgotha Monastery on Papa Stronsay for approximately two years.

He was a member of the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer, a religious community based on the remote island. Within the community, he was also known as Brother Ignatius Maria.

The Diocese of Aberdeen described him as a member of the Redemptorist community and remembered him for his humility and charity.

His disappearance deeply affected his family, fellow members of the religious community and people connected to the wider Orkney area.

Roman Catholic Diocese of Aberdeen+1

When Did Justin Evans Go Missing?

Police Scotland said Evans was last seen within Golgotha Monastery shortly before midnight on Saturday, April 11, 2026.

He was reported missing on Sunday, April 12.

At the time, police described him as approximately six feet tall, with short hair and a dark beard. He spoke with a New Zealand accent and was reported to have been wearing a robe when last seen.

Inspector David Hall appealed to anyone who had visited Papa Stronsay or had information about Evans and his whereabouts to contact police.

Searches were carried out around the island and neighbouring coastal areas as concerns grew about his disappearance.

Extensive Search Across Papa Stronsay and Nearby Waters

The search for Evans involved several emergency and specialist teams.

Police Scotland worked with coastguard personnel and other partner agencies to examine areas around Papa Stronsay and nearby islands.

As the investigation continued, specialist marine police officers and divers joined the operation. Search teams also examined coastal locations and underwater areas.

Papa Stronsay is a small island east of mainland Orkney, and its remote setting presented particular challenges for the search.

On April 29, The Orcadian reported that a police boat and dive team had joined the operation. The search continued into early May before a body was discovered.

Body Recovered Near Stronsay

On the morning of May 6, 2026, a body was recovered from the water near Stronsay.

Police Scotland confirmed that officers were responding to the discovery at approximately 7:35 a.m. Kirkwall Coastguard Rescue Team and a Kirkwall RNLI lifeboat also attended.

At the time of the discovery, police said the death was being treated as unexplained while enquiries continued.

The body was subsequently formally identified as Justin Evans, also known as Brother Ignatius Maria. His relatives were informed, and Police Scotland said there were no suspicious circumstances surrounding his death.

What Happened to Justin Evans? New Details From the Investigation

Fresh information about the investigation emerged in November through reporting on the BBC documentary series Highland Cops.

According to The Orcadian, the documentary examined material recovered during police enquiries, including a digital diary kept by Evans. Officers reviewed his writings and spoke with members of the monastery community as part of their efforts to understand the circumstances leading up to his disappearance.

The diary contained personal reflections and theological writing. An officer involved in reviewing it said the entries helped provide insight into Evans’s thoughts before he went missing.

The documentary also discussed clothing belonging to Evans that was discovered on the island after his disappearance, as well as a cord associated with membership of the religious community.

Police officers described how the search gradually shifted towards the possibility that they were looking for his body after extensive enquiries failed to establish that he had left the island.

The reporting also stated that investigators found no indication in the diary that Evans had planned to leave the island or take his own life. An examination of his body reportedly found no injuries or marks suggesting foul play. These findings were discussed in the context of the police investigation, rather than as a public explanation of every circumstance surrounding his disappearance.

Investigation Into His Death Officially Closed

On October 25, 2026, The Orcadian reported that the case had officially closed.

The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service confirmed that it had received a report concerning the death of a 25-year-old man in Orkney on May 6.

Following a thorough investigation, the Procurator Fiscal concluded that no further action was required. Evans’s family had been informed of the decision.

The religious community had previously said that Evans was presumed to have drowned at sea, while acknowledging that the circumstances of his disappearance and death remained unclear.

Justin Evans Laid to Rest on Papa Stronsay

Justin Evans was buried on Papa Stronsay on May 13, 2026. Members of his family travelled from New Zealand to attend the funeral.

The Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer remembered him in a message following the service, expressing the loss felt by those who knew him.

The Diocese of Aberdeen had also offered prayers and condolences to his family and religious community following the disappearance and presumed death announcement.

Highland Cops Documentary Revisits the Missing Monk Case

The disappearance has received renewed attention through Highland Cops: The Missing Monk, an episode examining the police response and investigation.

The programme follows officers as they travel to Papa Stronsay, speak with members of the monastery and review material connected to Evans’s final days.

According to the November 13 report by the Press and Journal, the episode was scheduled to air on BBC Scotland on Sunday, November 15, 2026, at 9 p.m.

Justin Evans Personal Details

Detail Information
Full name Justin Evans
Religious name Brother Ignatius Maria
Age when reported missing 24
Age reported by Crown Office at death 25
Originally from Christchurch, New Zealand
Last known location Golgotha Monastery, Papa Stronsay, Orkney, Scotland
Date last seen April 11, 2026
Reported missing April 12, 2026
Body recovered May 6, 2026
Formal identification May 11, 2026
Burial May 13, 2026
Cause or circumstances Presumed to have drowned at sea; full circumstances not publicly established
Investigation status Closed; no further action required

Frequently Asked Questions

Who was the missing monk on Papa Stronsay?

The missing monk was Justin Evans, a New Zealander also known as Brother Ignatius Maria, who lived at Golgotha Monastery.

When did Justin Evans disappear?

He was last seen shortly before midnight on April 11, 2026, and was reported missing on April 12.

Was Justin Evans found?

Yes. His body was recovered from the water near Stronsay on May 6, 2026, and formally identified as Justin Evans.

What happened to the Papa Stronsay monk?

The religious community said he was presumed to have drowned at sea. Police found no suspicious circumstances, and the Procurator Fiscal later concluded that no further action was required.

Has the investigation been closed?

Yes. The Orcadian reported on October 25, 2026, that the case was officially closed following the Procurator Fiscal’s decision.

Conclusion

The disappearance of Justin Evans from Papa Stronsay brought a major search operation to the remote Orkney island and surrounding waters. The discovery of his body on May 6 ended the search, while the subsequent investigation found no suspicious circumstances and resulted in a decision that no further action was required.

Through the recent Highland Cops documentary coverage, further details have emerged about the police enquiries, the diary reviewed by investigators and the efforts made to establish what happened before Evans disappeared.

Justin, remembered as Brother Ignatius Maria, was laid to rest on Papa Stronsay in May. His family, fellow monks and those who knew him continue to remember his life and the circumstances of his tragic loss.

Disclaimer: This article is based on reporting from November 2026, information from Police Scotland, the Diocese of Aberdeen and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. The community presumed that Justin Evans drowned at sea, but the complete circumstances of his disappearance and death have not been publicly established. The investigation was closed with no further action required.

For more updates, please check our social media platform

Thank you for reading.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *